Log in

No account? Create an account
latest entries related journals calendar about the author My life in pictures older entries older entries more recent entries more recent entries
My Thoughts Today
An ill-used association of words and pictures
Letter to my MP regarding the Digital Economy Bill
Dear Andrew Love,

Thank you very much for your letter dated 22nd March in response to my email enquiry concerning the Digital Economy Bill.

I understand that the Digital Economy Bill will receive its second reading in the House of Commons on April 6th following which it could well be passed without further scrutiny as part of the washing up process prior to the forthcoming General Election.

With the institution of Parliament already in such low regard amongst the electorate I'm frankly mystified that MPs are taking such a cavalier approach to legislation which appears to disproportionately favour a narrow special interest group (in particular the BPI) whilst at the same time introducing a new statutory instrument allowing future modification of copyright law without recourse to Parliament.

The major record labels have long been a joke in the digital economy, not because anyone wishes to 'steal' the content they publish but because of their inability to adapt to changing circumstances and determination to criminalise their potential customer base rather than provide the products and services which the market is overwhelmingly crying out for.

For a piece of legislation which is supposed to promote innovation in this sphere to further entrench their antiquated business models at the expense of the much greater economic benefit to be gained from embracing new technologies seems perverse in the extreme.

I have personally worked on a digital distribution project in collaboration with Virgin Media and the major record labels which would have brought customers the convenience they desire whilst at the same time protecting the intellectual property rights of the record labels. Today's illegal down-loaders would have been converted into tomorrow's loyal customers. Unfortunately that project was cancelled in February of last year.

Not I should point out because of any lack of a market or of opportunity for all concerned to profit, but because the additional protections demanded by these same record labels (which in any event would not have provided any greater technical security) made it impossible for Virgin Media to profit from running the service.

And if Virgin Media can't reach a workable deal with these dinosaurs, what hope for any smaller company?

As to the three-strikes aspect of the legislation, the lack of technical clue amongst Parliamentarians in general is just staggering.

Not only are consumer-grade wireless networks fundamentally insecure, so to is the Windows operating system which the majority of personal computers in this country utilise. Co-opting either to illegally download copyrighted media is trivial for those of appropriate disposition, as is removing any forensic trace of their having done so.

Nor for that matter can the identity of the computer or computers performing such downloads be ascertained beyond reasonable doubt or even on the balance of probability unless the latter is defined in such a manner as to presume guilt with the burden of proving innocence falling squarely on the shoulders of the accused. That hardly seems a favourable addition to English Law.

Then there's Clause 43 which effectively destroys private photographic copyright. Not only is this a priori an incredibly stupid idea, as a software developer I'm greatly concerned that a few years down the road the same rules will be extended to cover copyrighted works in other media. If this is not to be the case it also raises the question of what is so special about photographic works that their creators should be so disproportionately singled out in this manner?

Frankly this is bad legislation, rushed through Parliament with inadequate scrutiny, and it reflects poorly on MPs that the majority are not demanding their right to rectify the glaring defects in its construction.

I trust that when the Digital Economy Bill receives its second reading you will register your opposition to its proceeding further.

Yours sincerely,

Eleanor McHugh

Tags: ,
today I am mostly: annoyed

7 opinions or participate
friend_of_tofu From: friend_of_tofu Date: March 25th, 2010 07:20 pm (UTC) (permanent link)
This is a fantastic letter. I may have to steal bits (obv not the bits about being a developer), would you mind?
feyeleanor From: feyeleanor Date: March 26th, 2010 11:29 am (UTC) (permanent link)
Please be my guest :)
friend_of_tofu From: friend_of_tofu Date: March 26th, 2010 11:31 am (UTC) (permanent link)
jellymillion From: jellymillion Date: March 26th, 2010 09:25 am (UTC) (permanent link)
I wish I had an MP worth writing to. Derek Conway (now probably seen mostly as an expense-fiddling trailblazer) is hardly the most engaged of politicians these days.
feyeleanor From: feyeleanor Date: March 26th, 2010 11:32 am (UTC) (permanent link)
Don't let apathy stand in the way of a good bit of righteous indignation :)
From: (Anonymous) Date: March 26th, 2010 06:27 pm (UTC) (permanent link)

Letter to me

Dear Ms McHugh
Thank you for writing to me and for putting the letter onto your website. I hope that as many people make their views (both positive and negative) about the issues that concern them known to their Members of Parliament.
With kind regards.
Andy Love MP
From: (Anonymous) Date: November 18th, 2012 08:26 am (UTC) (permanent link)

www.louisvuittonoutletlondon.co.uk louis vuitton nosl

[b][url=http://www.bestlouisvuittonhandbags.co.uk/]louis vuitton handbags[/url][/b] Generally we've seen woman carried other form of shoulder bags like black leather-based purse and brown hobo bags. Whether or not you may have a straightforward position and shoot camera or DSLR camera and a 50 percent dozen lenses, you're almost certainly taking a look at camera bags to safeguard your gear. I used to be just searching for the catalogue about the formal site of Gucci, desperately looking for anything much less puking as usual.
Developer polarized solar shades have wonderful seems and several variants so that you can pick from. These shades are cost-effective maybe. Most brand names of custom manufactured polarized sunglasses charge about Buck200 or maybe more. Many of us are aware that Bottega Veneta's types are actually a luxurious. We also are aware that most (if not all) of their layouts hold similarly deluxe cost tags. Though woven nappa leather style is precisely what the model is recognized for, time passes and they're too currently being recognised to layout bags which come from unique skins..

[b][url=http://www.louisvuittononlinesalestore.com/]louis vuitton on sale[/url][/b] Another eight days of class have been significant chaos. I used to be capable to witness the early phases of students possessing "the embodied expertise of participating in purposeful orchestration of modes to set-up meaning" (Miller 66; italics in first). Students slipped into character.
When he is obtaining off track, he employs the J stroke or the steering stroke. The J stroke is simply a ahead carry by means of just after the facility stroke; this requires the bow to proper or left. The steering stroke is actually retaining the blade from the paddle a tiny bit angled throughout the stroke and holding it to get a few seconds on the end of the stroke, just like a rudder; this also steers the bow to correct or remaining..

[b][url=http://www.uggsclearancestore.co.uk/]ugg clearance[/url][/b] Costs always increase at the grocery store. I have seen my own grocery spending plan rise by just about $100 per 30 days (while several rising boys could be contributing to that enhance). Gone would be the days of 4 bins of spaghetti for any buck but total, pasta remains a reasonable and filling beginning to several foods.
Professional persons and psyched commentators rattled and prattled on about windshifts and gear failure and tactical conclusions that might be manufactured. There's 'luffs' and 'beats to windward' and plenty of incomprehensible nautical conditions past the ken of many of us but since the graphics confirmed Prada - elegant and trim in grey - was inching forward. Plus the Kiwis had been all holding their breath and observing together with the avidness of any sports activities fan.

[b][url=http://www.louisvuittononlinesalestore.com/]www.louisvuittononlinesalestore.com[/url][/b] No dialogue of organization conversation nowadays could be total with out working with the most well-liked strategy of trading arguments right now E-mail has changed informal conversation as the most frequent signifies of exchanging company information and facts, telling jokes, and spreading gossip. Texting is presenting it a operate to make sure. Context during the Matter Line: If you need your electronic mail to become opened by any means, your matter line greater contain some context the target recipient can relate to or it can strike the SPAM file more quickly than you can strike ship.
Fashionable in Damier canvas, this Papillon bag options the pretty spherical shape. Golden brass pieces add a contact of vintage towards the totality. So it is actually surely the timeless purse which often can hold you classy for years to come back. Usually called the North's unofficial funds, Leeds is actually a entertaining place. It's bought a historic inhabitants of almost 450,000. Also to its several residents, Leeds also attracts quite a few enterprise travellers and holidaymakers.
[b][url=http://www.uggsclearancestore.co.uk/]ugg outlet[/url][/b]
7 opinions or participate